诡计x逻辑案件盘点

诡计x逻辑案件盘点

  ⊙﹏⊙b汗,本来只是想扔到推理游戏合集里面的,结果越写越长,干脆独立出来,这样也不会显得喧宾夺主。

前言

  这个游戏算是非常硬核的本格推理游戏,推理短篇合集,作者包括麻耶雄蒿、我孙子武丸、大山诚一郎、绫辻行人、有栖川有栖等,堪称本格推理全明星阵容。唯一的问题是没有完整汉化,目前仅第一季有部分汉化,所以我就着兔碳的实况落樱时节的文本翻译完成了本作游玩。后PS:第二季也有了,在这里

  另外也要碎碎念这个系统,就算你知道Trick了也得慢慢穷举把闪现凑出来,结果无限拉长游戏时间,很容易劝退玩家。而且有些闪现很不合理,根本就很难理解为什么能组合,事实上不看攻略的情况下想凑齐全闪现和解答是非常困难的,逼死本强迫症。

  【泄底警告】虽然我已经尽可能避免泄底了,不过如果你对推理小说有一定阅读量可能会被我有意无意的泄底,所以往下阅读请慎重。

主线

  没错,这个游戏也是有主线的!男主角有点像御剑怜侍,连背景设定都很像,父亲也是个律师hhhhh。这里讲的是男主在阎魔和女主等帮助下完成自我救赎,不再是一个偏激且不择手段的检察官的故事,逆转粉会心一笑好吧。

分集

尸体所指

  作为初始教程的谜题,相对来说比较简单,结果受限于系统设定试了好久才把线索凑齐。

被盗的手办

  作者我孙子武丸,没有凶案,剧情让俺想到了某师弟,四斋蒸鹅心啊。Trick依然很简单,在某著名作品里面用过了,不过在80多页里面找关键词来凑闪现还是花了我一下午时间,搞的网课也没怎么听,血亏!

光线消失的房间

  作者竹本健治,写过四大奇书之一的《 匣中失乐》,平心而论《匣中失乐》有点故弄玄虚,相对而言这篇给我的感觉还行。难度不大,基本上凭直觉就知道凶手了,然后Trick也不难猜到,就是那个闪现太难凑了,居然要尸僵和“ 运动神经看起来相当不错的阳光青年 ”组合,让人不明所以,也有可能是翻译问题,反正本日文苦手就没法深究了。

飘雪的女生宿舍

  作者麻耶雄嵩!虽然麻神的作品相当放飞自我,结果这个谜题的设计还是挺精巧的。死亡信息也是本格推理中很常见的元素,不过也仅仅是在作品中很常见, 现实生活中留下那种需要人猜的信息还是挺少见的。这篇也是和死亡信息有关,重点是为什么凶手要在早上返回消除死亡信息,想明白这点就能经过逻辑排除推出凶手了。只能说细节还是埋的挺巧妙的,但是小说越来越长了,这次是在200页里面翻关键词,我要吐了。

被斩断的五首

  作者大山诚一郎!他的短篇集《密室收藏家》和《赤色博物馆》都是我很喜欢的作品,所以对这篇我也报以很大期望。然而这个故事真的很难,还是叙诡,强烈怀疑和上篇麻神的名字弄混了hhh。

  回到本篇,这篇里面出现了无面尸元素,读的时候我第一感觉是身份互换,没想到后面作者亲自在剧情里驳斥了这个观点把我打脸了。反正俺是没想出来答案,只能看了提示才解出来,但是最后的答案真的把我气笑了,有种看《消失!》的感觉。不过细想一下该给的线索也给了,就是不知道有没有大佬凭自己本事推理出来。

亡灵哈姆雷特

  作者黑田研二,他最出名的作品是《婚纱》,不过我还没读23333,这个作者最牛的地方还是能把《逆转裁判》和《极限脱出》等游戏IP都拿到改编权出书,有点东西,虽然质量似乎挺一般的。围绕监控器做文章也是近些年科技进步对古典推理的冲击吧。扯一嘴,这方面的文给我印象深刻的有《全部成为F》、《玻璃之锤》以及日剧《上锁的房间》的SP(因为俺没看贵志祐介的其他小说,不确定是否有原著改编)等等。

  说回来这个故事,再次说明画时刻表和示意图在本格推理阅读的重要性!如果对比示意图,大概也能理解凶手交换的目的所在了,然后也不难猜出手法。总的来说还是挺公平的推理了,该埋的伏笔都有了。

血腥玛丽之谜

  作者竹本健治。这篇怎么说呢,感觉挺一般的。虽然逻辑上行得通,也可以推导出来,但是我觉得有点浪费时间,也没什么惊喜。我不太喜欢Trick被限定到极其局限的地步,这篇恰恰如此,只能在很特定的情况下实现,感觉有点欺负被害者的感觉hhhh。当然内容很点题,大概就是为了这个题目设计的Trick?话说我这样是不是算泄底了。

来复线的谋杀

  作者麻神。这篇有岛田流的风格,在一个湖中的小岛——高丽岛上,著名幻想作家被射杀,桌上留下了Dying Message:“奇迹”,奇怪的是,窗外正对着的却是悬崖……Trick倒是有点像某《三星馆杀人事件》(大雾),好像又泄底了。但是我还是觉得有点雷人,至少森博嗣那篇还能让我觉得有点道理,而在这里的话真的能那么巧嘛?可能要归结于大自然的鬼斧神工吧。貌似作者也用了日语梗暗示了,可惜俺没法get到。

  所以就这点而言我觉得这个故事设计的挺失败的。而且这篇的流程设计也不是很合理,正推的话必须依赖犯人的误解来判断凶手,反推的话,在你预设了一个凶手然后系统会硬给你塞线索,闪现直接就把Trick点出来了,又有点强行降低难度了的感觉。反正就很迷,大概也是因为这个故事的Trick立意不好带来的后果吧。

视线铁壁的密室

  大山诚一郎,永远滴神!感觉这篇是本季质量最高的了。本篇是一个看似不可能完成的视线密室,通过不同人的视角来描述案件过程,似乎还用到了一点叙述性诡计。里面细节非常多,而且很有逻辑性,列出时间线并从一一击破游戏里的谜题,最终推导出结论的感觉非常爽快,非常值得一玩。

Y的目标

  绫辻行人、有栖川有栖携手打造大型生草剧本,拜阳教教主被石头砸死在中庭,文本非常非常的长,渲染很多,感觉全是废话。不过确实把我给难住了,可能是我也没想到还能设计这种手法吧,真是太耍流氓了!总之是我举手投降的岛田流剧本,难怪敢直接标题泄底的,我看到标题第一印象还以为是致敬奎因,害。

完美无缺的不在场证明

  作者我孙子武丸。第一眼看上去感觉是时刻表诡计,时刻表诡计在日系推理中还是很常见的,代表作松本清张的《点与线》、岛田庄司的《出云传说7/8杀人事件》等,大山诚一郎的《伪证破解家》也可以作为不在场证明讲义来看。虽然是很讲逻辑性的推理小说套路,但是个人感觉解起来没那些不可能犯罪有意思。

  这篇作为压轴感觉弱了点,列完时间线后就感觉每个人都不足以犯案,那么就只有一种可能了!感觉有点像阿婆的某不朽名作hhh,替店长点根蜡烛。

暴走的朱丽叶

  番外篇,和主线没有关联,算是一个独立的小说。作者黑田研二,Trick和上面的某篇有一点点像,感觉有点雷人,不过既然是番外篇也就不计较那么多了。

结局

  到最后又接上了主线,揭示了主角和父亲的案件的真凶,也正是主角一直给他们提供帮助,才让事件发展到最后真相大白,有一种善恶有报的因果论的感觉,最后一段动画还挺帅的。

  总的来说,游戏质量还是挺高的,私以为必玩的有《视线铁壁的密室》、《飘雪的女生宿舍》,有争议的有《被斩断的五首》,其他的也算基本上水准在线,是本格推理迷应玩的佳作了~

评论

3D cell culture 3D cell culturing 3D cell microarrays 3D culture 3D culture model 3D printing 3D spheroid 3D tumor culture 3D tumors 3D vascular mapping ACT ADV AUTODESK Abdominal wall defects Acoustofluidics Adipocyte Adipogenesis Adoptive cell therapy AirPods Alginate Anticancer Anticancer agents Anticancer drugs Apple Apriori Association Analysis August AutoCAD Autodock Vina Bio-inspired systems Biochannels Bioengineering Bioinspired Biological physics Biomarkers Biomaterial Biomaterials Biomimetic materials Biomimetics Bioprinting Blood purification Blood-brain barrier Bone regeneration Breast cancer Breast cancer cells Breast neoplasms CM1860 CRISPR/Cas9 system CSS CTC isolation CTCs Cancer Cancer angiogenesis Cancer cell invasion Cancer immunity Cancer immunotherapy Cancer metabolism Cancer metastasis Cancer models Cancer screening Cancer stem cells Cell adhesion Cell arrays Cell assembly Cell clusters Cell culture Cell culture techniques Cell mechanical stimulation Cell morphology Cell trapping Cell-bead pairing Cell-cell interaction Cell-laden gelatin methacrylate Cellular uptake Cell−cell interaction Cervical cancer Cheminformatics Chemotherapy Chimeric antigen receptor-T cells Chip interface Circulating tumor cells Clinical diagnostics Cmder Co-culture Coculture Colon Colorectal cancer Combinatorial drug screening Combinatorial drug testing Compartmentalized devices Confined migration Continuous flow Convolutional neural network Cooking Crawler Cryostat Curved geometry Cytokine detection Cytometry Cytotoxicity Cytotoxicity assay DESeq DNA tensioners Data Mining Deep learning Deformability Delaunay triangulation Detective story Diabetic wound healing Diagnostics Dielectrophoresis Differentiation Digital microfluidics Direct reprogramming Discrimination of heterogenic CTCs Django Double emulsion microfluidics Droplet Droplet microfluidics Droplets generation Droplet‐based microfluidics Drug combination Drug efficacy evaluation Drug evaluation Drug metabolism Drug resistance Drug resistance screening Drug screening Drug testing Dual isolation and profiling Dynamic culture Earphone Efficiency Efficiency of encapsulation Elastomers Embedded 3D bioprinting Encapsulation Endothelial cell Endothelial cells English Environmental hazard assessment Epithelial–mesenchymal transition Euclidean distance Exosome biogenesis Exosomes Experiment Extracellular vesicles FC40 FP-growth Fabrication Fast prototyping Fibroblasts Fibrous strands Fiddler Flask Flow rates Fluorescence‐activated cell sorting Functional drug testing GEO Galgame Game Gene Expression Profiling Gene delivery Gene expression profiling Gene targetic Genetic association Gene‐editing Gigabyte Glypican-1 GoldenDict Google Translate Gradient generator Growth factor G‐CSF HBEXO-Chip HTML Hanging drop Head and neck cancer Hectorite nanoclay Hepatic models Hepatocytes Heterotypic tumor HiPSCs High throughput analyses High-throughput High-throughput drug screening High-throughput screening assays High‐throughput methods Histopathology Human neural stem cells Human skin equivalent Hydrogel Hydrogel hypoxia Hydrogels ImageJ Immune checkpoint blockade Immune-cell infiltration Immunoassay Immunological surveillance Immunotherapy In vitro tests In vivo mimicking Induced hepatocytes Innervation Insulin resistance Insulin signaling Interferon‐gamma Intestinal stem cells Intracellular delivery Intratumoral heterogeneity JRPG Jaccard coefficient JavaScript July June KNN Kidney-on-a-chip Lab-on-a-chip Laptop Large scale Lattice resoning Leica Leukapheresis Link Lipid metabolism Liquid biopsy Literature Liver Liver microenvironment Liver spheroid Luminal mechanics Lung cells MOE Machine Learning Machine learning Macro Macromolecule delivery Macroporous microgel scaffolds Magnetic field Magnetic sorting Malignant potential Mammary tumor organoids Manhattan distance Manual Materials science May Mechanical forces Melanoma Mesenchymal stem cells Mesoporous silica particles (MSNs) Metastasis Microassembly Microcapsule Microcontact printing Microdroplets Microenvironment Microfluidic array Microfluidic chips Microfluidic device Microfluidic droplet Microfluidic organ-on-a chip Microfluidic organ-on-a-chip Microfluidic patterning Microfluidic screening Microfluidic tumor models Microfluidic-blow-spinning Microfluidics Microneedles Micropatterning Microtexture Microvascular Microvascular networks Microvasculatures Microwells Mini-guts Mirco-droplets Molecular docking Molecular imprinting Monolith Monthly Multi-Size 3D tumors Multi-organoid-on-chip Multicellular spheroids Multicellular systems Multicellular tumor aggregates Multi‐step cascade reactions Myeloid-derived suppressor cells NK cell NanoZoomer Nanomaterials Nanoparticle delivery Nanoparticle drug delivery Nanoparticles Nanowell Natural killer cells Neural progenitor cell Neuroblastoma Neuronal cell Neurons Nintendo Nissl body Node.js On-Chip orthogonal Analysis OpenBabel Organ-on-a-chip Organ-on-a-chip devices Organically modified ceramics Organoids Organ‐on‐a‐chip Osteochondral interface Oxygen control Oxygen gradients Oxygen microenvironments PDA-modified lung scaffolds PDMS PTX‐loaded liposomes Pain relief Pancreatic cancer Pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma Pancreatic islet Pathology Patient-derived organoid Patient-derived tumor model Patterning Pearl powder Pearson coefficient Penetralium Perfusable Personalized medicine Photocytotoxicity Photodynamic therapy (PDT) Physiological geometry Pluronic F127 Pneumatic valve Poetry Polymer giant unilamellar vesicles Polystyrene PowerShell Precision medicine Preclinical models Premetastatic niche Primary cell transfection Printing Protein patterning Protein secretion Pubmed PyMOL Pybel Pytesseract Python Quasi-static hydrodynamic capture R RDKit RNAi nanomedicine RPG Reactive oxygen species Reagents preparation Resistance Review Rod-shaped microgels STRING Selective isolation Self-assembly Self-healing hydrogel September Signal transduction Silk-collagen biomaterial composite Similarity Single cell Single cells Single molecule Single-cell Single-cell RNA sequencing Single‐cell analysis Single‐cell printing Size exclusion Skin regeneration Soft lithography Softstar Spheroids Spheroids-on-chips Staining StarBase Stem cells Sub-Poisson distribution Supramolecular chemistry Surface chemistry Surface modification Switch T cell function TCGA Tanimoto coefficient The Millennium Destiny The Wind Road Thin gel Tissue engineering Transcriptome Transfection Transient receptor potential channel modulators Tropism Tubulogenesis Tumor environmental Tumor exosomes Tumor growth and invasion Tumor immunotherapy Tumor metastasis Tumor microenvironment Tumor response Tumor sizes Tumor spheroid Tumor-on-a-chip Tumorsphere Tumors‐on‐a‐chip Type 2 diabetes mellitus Ultrasensitive detection Unboxing Underlying mechanism Vascularization Vascularized model Vasculature Visual novel Wettability Windows Terminal Word Writing Wuxia Xenoblade Chronicles Xin dynasty XuanYuan Sword Youdao cnpm fsevents miR-125b-5p miR-214-3p miRNA signature miRanda npm
Your browser is out-of-date!

Update your browser to view this website correctly. Update my browser now

×